Yummy Gummies: The Anti-Cavity Candy

A teeth healing diet is full of delicious food options, but sweetness is not its main flavour. Everyone knows that sugar is bad for your teeth, though its a well-kept secret that the reason is not what most people think. It's not the sugar in your mouth causing plaque that create cavities but the sugar in your blood stream. When our blood sugar levels are elevated the body isn't able to manufacture the hormones and proteins that naturally and continuously remineralise teeth.   

Sugar is everywhere. It hides discreetly in almost every single packaged and processed food. But of course it's out flaunting itself as well, in bakery cabinets, birthday parties, convenience store refrigerators and almost everywhere else you look. And because sugar is addictive, the flaunted sugar is often hard to resist, even when you are being vigilant about avoiding the hidden sugars in mayonnaise, pasta sauce or bread.

Download the free e-book today.

Download the free e-book today.

One of my principles of holistic teeth healing is that you can start to heal your teeth by adding helpful foods before you start removing the unhelpful foods, so I don't advocate that sugar addicts have to give up all sugar in order to heal your teeth. But cutting back on refined sugar is definitely a good idea, and if you have already embraced a sugar-free life, your teeth are thanking you for it.

Sometimes when you need a sweet treat to share with children or to feed the child within, its good to have an option with no fructose, minimal glucose and as much tooth healing goodness as you can squeeze in. And that's where the magic of gelatin (or gelatine) comes into its own. 

Gelatin is a concentrated teeth healing food, equivalent to bone broth in its delivery of protein and minerals.  I'm not talking about jello, which is mostly sugar, but the plain unsweetened gelatin powder, ideally sourced from grass-fed, organically cattle.  This good quality gelatin is more difficult to find- I have to order mine online- and much more expensive than the regular plain gelatin sold in my supermarket. But oh, the things that it will do for your teeth. 

Dissolve gelatine in cold water before you add it to anything else

Dissolve gelatine in cold water before you add it to anything else

My favourite way to consume gelatin is as teeth healing gummies.   There are infinite variations to satisfy every kind of sweet craving. This week, in the Southern Hemisphere summer I used some of the glut of plums from our garden and whole, heavy, summer-grass-fed cream for a double whammy of teeth healing goodness.  You can use whatever you have available. 

Anti-Cavity Candy Formula

Rather than giving a recipe, I'm sharing the formula so you can change it up to suit your taste and what's available.


1 1/2 cups of fruit and liquid in any proportion and combination

3 1/2 tablespoons of high quality gelatin dissolved in 1/2 cup cold water (flouride-free if you can get it)

1/2-2 tsp of optional sweetener 

Suggestions for fruit: plums, peaches, strawberries, raspberries, blueberries, cherries, apples, pears, mango, etc. Kiwi, pineapple and most citrus are too acidic to set well (and are hard on the teeth).

Suggestions for liquid: cream, milk, coconut milk, kombucha, kefir, yogurt, herbal tea, green tea, water, left over smoothie, fresh vegetable or fruit juice etc

Suggestions for optional sweeteners: raw honey, organic maple syrup, stevia

Plums and cream totalling 1 1/2 cups

Plums and cream totalling 1 1/2 cups


Heat fruit and liquid slowly until hot but not boiling, then cool slightly and blend, mash or mouli til smooth.

Dissolve gelatin into cold water and let it sit 5 minutes then stir to break up the gel. 

Add the gelatin lumps into the warm fruit mixture and stir until smooth. Pour into molds or a shallow container and leave to set in the refrigerator for 2 hours. Keeps in the refrigerator for up to a week.

Teeth healing gelatin gummies are quick and easy sugar-free treats to make at home. Perfect for kids parties, pot lucks and everyday snacks. 

Teeth healing gelatin gummies are quick and easy sugar-free treats to make at home. Perfect for kids parties, pot lucks and everyday snacks. 

For more teeth healing recipes, tips and practical strategies delivered straight to your inbox, join the Holistic Tooth Fairy Circle.